Portugal Safety and Security Report Wednesday 30th August 2023

Good morning everyone. Well after a hot and dry period for many parts of the country in recent weeks, which has facilitated an average of some 82 fires a day over the last week alone, there are indications that the weather may change for the better, or worse, depending on your perspective. Better in those areas that need rain, worse if it comes in the form of downbursts that cause flooding and danger to people and property.

Various metrological models have been pointing for several days to the possibility of a situation that would produce instability with showers, thunderstorms, hail and strong gusts of wind throughout the country, in early September. However the weekend of the 2nd/3rd of September is still difficult to predict, due to Hurricane Franklin, a cyclone that will not touch land, but which will move the atmospheric elements and can complicate the forecast.

The “hand-to-hand struggle” between Franklin and the Azores High will be decisive to how the weather will evolve from early September on the mainland. We are monitoring closely.

Sometimes it is easy to become sceptical about weather forecasting, with what was predicted not coming to fruition, but with far improved technology available these days, it has in fact become far more accurate – due mainly to advanced satellites that can produce more information and imaging thus helping metreologists. Clearly the more accurate the information, the quality of the analysis and accuracy of bulletins, and most important timing, can help people prepare and thus reduce the impact of any natural disasters. The above is an example of the challenges they face.

However, one good example a few days ago was the charts and information produced by ESTOFEX the European Storm Warning system, which we published on our new Facebook group on Saturday morning, which gave very detailed indication of developing storms in parts of Europe particularly the Balearic Islands and Sardinia, which the following day came to fruition with storms and large hailstorms that cause considerable damage.

The live lightning site – meteoredpt showed several hours beforehand a huge number of electrical discharges approaching Sardinia. We published this and a few hours later there were high winds storms and considerable damage.

Although this did not impact Portugal these metrological tools are available for anyone to see and one does not need to be a meteorologist to realize the likely impact. The examples of extreme weather are everywhere to be seen and of course is not immune to this. So the moral of all this is to really study the forecasts in particular the wording from organisations such as, ESTROFEX, ECMWF, AMEAT, IPMA, and xxx to name but a few. Forewarned is forearmed. A simple analogy, would you delay getting treatment if all the evidence showed you had an illness – no of course not. The same goes for the forecasting of weather that could cause life threatening results or damage!

Scientists have, however highlighted the difficulty in anticipating extreme weather events, which are, by definition, rare. They argue that weather models are changing very quickly which leaves the world “partly flying blind” towards an increasingly unpredictable future.

July was the hottest month in human history and people across the world are suffering the consequences,” says Professor Piers Forster of the University of Leeds in the UK. “But this is what we would expect at this level of warming. This will be the average summer for 10 years unless the world cooperates and puts climate action at the top of the agenda.”

We are much more vulnerable than we thought. Our vulnerability is slapping us in the face” warn experts who make it clear, once again, that urgent pro-climate action is needed. From high temperatures to sudden torrential downpours, from wildfires to drought, “crazy” extreme weather conditions are just the “tip of the iceberg”, warn scientists.

Within a decade – if there is no strong climate strategy – the extreme weather events of 2023 will become the new normal, the world’s leading climate researchers told the British publication the Guardian, which asked them for an assessment of the climate crisis. See report in full below.

A sobering thought to end this introduction

Welcome back to Susan (website and our Northern Facebook group) from her well-deserved break.

Have a good week ahead.

News

Radical change is needed to reduce ‘crazy’ weather conditions, scientists warn

Torrential rains triggered flash floods in Aurdal, Norway, August 2023

The “crazy” episodes that the planet is already facing are just the “tip of the iceberg” compared to the “even worse effects that are yet to come”, they claim.

Scientists highlighted the difficulty in anticipating extreme weather events, which are, by definition, rare. They argue that weather models are changing very quickly which leaves the world “partly flying blind” towards an increasingly unpredictable future.

“July was the hottest month in human history and people across the world are suffering the consequences,” says Professor Piers Forster of the University of Leeds in the UK. “But this is what we would expect at this level of warming. This will be the average summer for 10 years unless the world cooperates and puts climate action at the top of the agenda.”

“The impacts are frighteningly more shocking than I – and many climate scientists I know – expected,” stresses Professor Krishna AchutaRao of the Indian Institute of Technology.

Christophe Cassou, CNRS researcher at Université Paul Sabatier Toulouse III in France, adds that “changes in [climate] risks have not been underestimated on a global scale. But the impacts, yes, were underestimated because we are much more vulnerable than we thought – our vulnerability is slapping us in the face”.

In 2023, temperatures are at historic highs and wildfires continue to devour millions of hectares of forest around the world, from North America to Europe and Asia. That’s why “we now feel that climate change is emerging above the normal climate” says Cassou.

Has the turning point already happened?

Scientists believe that the planet has not yet passed the tipping point for runaway climate change. But Rein Haarsma, of the Royal Netherlands Meteorological Institute, warns that that moment is approaching. “The extremes we see happening now could induce tipping points, such as the collapse of the Atlantic meridional circulation and the melting of the Antarctic ice sheets, which have devastating impacts.”

However, scientists say that a “small window” of opportunity remains open to avoid the worst of the climate crisis, and they point the finger at the use of fossil fuels.

“We need to stop burning fossil fuels”, reiterates Friederike Otto, from Imperial College London. He says it is imperative: “Now. This is not a time to allow companies to continue to make as much money as possible”.

Also joined by the critical voice of Emily Shuckburgh, from the University of Cambridge, UK: “Anyone who in any way perpetuates the fossil fuel age is firmly on the wrong side of history”.

“Knowing that we will look back on today’s extreme events as soft on what’s in our future is truly alarming,” adds Andrea Dutton of the University of Wisconsin-Madison, USA. And she leaves a clear message: “The speed with which we make this transition will define the future we will have.”

 

Portugal Safety and Security Report Wednesday 23rd August 2023.

 

From floods in Chili, British Colombia, to wild fire in Greece, Tenerife and Canada to name but a few, it appears that we are seeing the impacts of extreme weather from many different countries at present.

We have been covering some of these events mainly in our Safe Communities Portugal Protection against Natural Disasters Group, as it is important to remember that these event do not stop at national borders or within regions, so the weather conditions say in the USA or Canada can be replicated elsewhere including Portugal. What can make a difference however is the risk reduction measures that are in place and how that can reduce the impact, such as the number of casualties. An example I would give of this is the reduction in risk by the cleaning of land, and how that helps reduce fires reaching properties.

Simple things like understanding more about the risk of fires, how they can burn with greater intensity and how they spread, are all things that we should be more aware off, simply because that means we are more prepared and can take the appropriate action accordingly. It is also important that children are aware so they themselves can see the warning signs, perhaps ahead of their parents.

When travelling overseas it is important to also be aware of the risks, and the contact points in case of emergencies. Put this on the check list before you go on holiday and if you are staying in a rural property ensure that it affords some protection from fires.

In the case of rural fires in Portugal there have been xx over the last xx days, which are facilitated by weather extremes but nearly all have a human cause, as the minister of International administration said yesterday, over two thirds of these are caused by negligence; namely not following the rules that are in place.

In response to the recent fires, 300 more operatives have been made available and pair of amphibious Fire Boss aircrafts – will be, until October 31st, pre-positioned in Portugal, in Castelo Branco.

We are now in a heatwave that will last for the next few days and on Mondays 33 weather stations registered temperatures of over 40C, increasing to xx yesterday. Of course it is much hotter in the sun, so everyone needs to be careful by not over exercising, and in particular those who undertake physical work outdoors. Take regular beaks, try and work in shaded areas if possible and of course drink water regularly 1.5 litres a day recommended by the health authority, to avoid dehydration.  Most important is care of young children and avoiding direct exposure to the sun.

Communicating key messages about being prepared is extremely important and I would like to that Owen Gee KissFm for allowing us air time on Sunday mornings to do precisely this. Feed-back is very positive and I hope that people have become more Fire Wise, in part, from listening to the advice given. We are now in our 13th year on Solid Gold Sunday and we thank those for listening in.

I mentioned earlier our new Facebook group and am pleased to announce as of this morning we have no less than 2000 members in a period of just 45 days since it was launched! Our Safe Communities team are delighted with this response as apart from the numbers, members are showing great interest in the subject of preparedness, which is the key message that government is trying to get across at present. Also encouraging is members sharing their own experiences and knowledge which is fundamental in developing greater resilience to natural hazards. So a big thank you.

Our team wishes you a good week ahead.

News:

Fire caused damage of 5.5 ME and destroyed 5,315 hectares in Proença-a-Nova

Proença-a-Nova, Castelo Branco, 22 Aug 2023 (Lusa) – The fire that broke out on the 4th in the municipality of Castelo Branco and which progressed to Proença-a-Nova caused damages of 5.5 million euros in the latter municipality and destroyed 5,315 hectares of forest.

“Despite all the work we have done, this fire affected an area of ​​5,315 hectares which, after a survey carried out by the municipal services, totaled damages worth 5,550,297 euros”, announced the mayor of Proença-a- New, Joao Lobo.

According to this mayor of the Castelo Branco district, the calculated value is divided into three fundamental areas: needs for post-fire emergency stabilization interventions – 2,683,576 euros, plus intervention on paved roads – 1,696,448 euros.

The affected municipal equipment totals 169,306 euros and private property, 1,000,966 euros.

For now, the executive informed the Chamber, on Monday, of the 6th Amendment to the Budget and Major Options of the Plan, “a new item having been created for immediate support to the population in the amount of 90 thousand euros”.

The municipal executive also announced that he will send the request for support to the Government to operationalize all the expenses presented.

Among the losses, there is the investment necessary to recover the affected infrastructure, to control erosion, to treat and protect slopes, to prevent contamination and silting and to recover water lines.

Public infrastructure, such as signs for pedestrian routes, enduro tracks, hang gliding tracks, via ferrata, road signs, containment of damage to biodiversity and private property, including animals, fruit trees, irrigation pipes , haystacks and agricultural attachments, utensils, agricultural tools and machinery, animal feed are also accounted for.

João Lobo highlighted the importance of cleaning the 100 meters of the protection strip for population settlements and the pioneering spirit of the municipality of Proença-a-Nova in creating regulations for the conversion of forest areas into agricultural areas in 2018, for fuel management areas in the 100 meters around the population centers.

Currently, the municipality has carried out eight interventions of “Condomínios de Aldeia” and has a further eight operations in the pipeline.

“We still have approved four AIGP (Integrated Landscape Management Areas), which total an area of ​​about 7,200 hectares”, underlined the mayor.

The fire that broke out on the 4th in the municipality of Castelo Branco progressed to the municipality of Proença-a-Nova and entered the resolution phase after two days.

According to the Institute for the Conservation of Nature and Forests (ICNF), the rural fires registered in Odemira and Castelo Branco in early August represent more than half of the total area burned in Portugal in 2023.

According to the most recent statistics from the ICNF, which account for the first half of August, Portugal has registered since January 1 of this year 27,802 hectares of burned area and 6,085 rural fires, which translates into the second lowest value in number of fires and fourth in terms of area burned since 2013.

The fire that broke out in São Teotónio, in the municipality of Odemira, on August 5, is the biggest recorded in Portugal this year, consuming at least 7,530 hectares of land, while the fire registered in Sarzedas, municipality of Castelo Branco, also this month, led to a total of 6,553 hectares of burned area.

 

 

 

Portugal Safety and Security Report Wednesday 16th August 2023

 

Good morning, something that has been troubling me over the last week is what led to the devastating rural fire in Maui, Hawaii, resulting in a death toll of 106 and at least 1300 missing. Not only could this turn out to be the largest death toll from a rural fire in the US in last 100 years as stated, but one of the worlds greatest disasters from a rural fire.

resulting in a death toll of around one hundred but almost certainly to increase much higher.

Following this the Minister of Internal Administration sent a very clear message on Monday that Portugal must be prepared for “extreme fires” like those that occurred in Hawaii and Canada.

José Luís Carneiro recalls that this year “we have the greatest number of resources ever”, but stresses that responsible behaviour on the part of the population is also needed. What in effect the Minister is saying that the fires may well be intense, not necessarily the same impact provided everyone is aware of the hazards and is prepared accordingly. The minister stressed that we are still in the middle of the critical period of fires and admits that this year “adverse conditions could last until the end of September, mid-October”.

Turning to the Maui fires, brush fires were already burning on 9th August. Those fires were stoked on Wednesday by a combination of low humidity and strong mountain winds, brought by Hurricane Dora, a Category 4 storm hundreds of miles to the south in the Pacific Ocean. No cause for the fire has yet been determined, but experts said one possibility was that active power lines that fell in high winds ignited the wildfire that ultimately spread to Lahaina.

This is the worst fire in terms of fatalities in over one hundred years in US territory. Although the focus is now very much on recovery, there are inevitable questions on what many residents are stating that there was a lack of warning. Fires as we know can occur any time, but one of the most important aspects of preparedness is knowing what the fire hazards are at the time and place.

In the case of Maui what has been reported is that at the time of the fire most of the island was experiencing worsening drought conditions in recent weeks which probably also contributed to the fire. Nearly 16 percent of Maui County was in a severe drought on Tuesday, according to the U.S. NOAA have daily Watches, Warnings or Advisories for three areas of Maui which shows alerts currently in effect for those areas and is normally updated every two-three minutes. Unfortunately it is not historical so no data for 8th August.

Also there was a hurricane passing to the south, with winds on 8th August peaking at between 80 km/h 107km/h. (Source US National weather centre)

Hurricanes are closely tracked by the highly effective US Hurricane Centre (NOAA) with estimates of wind strengths, direction of the hurricane and relevant data which is published every few hours.

Fire danger info is provided to the population through various communication channels when deemed necessary (mid to high likability of fires to occur): TV, radio, and by text message. They also have a fire alert system, which is known by the public and has been used in the past. According to the news, this system has not been activated this time and the population was not correctly alerted. However, the danger of fires has been reported through regular means, as explained above.  On that day, a message has been sent to inform the population about the potential danger of fires. However, it is said that due to power outages (because of strong winds), the message might have not reached everyone.

 

Hawaii has what it says is one of the world’s largest siren systems to warn people of all kinds of events, including wildfires and hurricanes. Maui County has 80. State records don’t indicate that the sirens sounded in Lahaina, according to the Associated Press.

When asked at a press conference why was the state not more prepared? Hawaii Gov. Josh Green response, “We’ve never experienced a wildfire that affected a city like this before.”

Following this fire there will be a major review with recommendations to try and avoid a repeat of this disaster where perhaps hundreds have died, in the future. The lessons learned affect not only the USA but also other countries where similar risks exist.

However it should not bring disasters to bring about change. We need to think ahead and plan ahead with the best knowledge and tools that are available. It should not be case that we were not prepared because we had not experience it before! Other countries have and we need to learn from their experiences, as Portugal did following the 2017 fires.

What this shows us is the importance of preparedness and when fires do take place the need to have a basic understanding of wildfires behaviour especially those live in fire prone areas.

With that please have a safe week ahead.

News

“Aldeia Segura” program: more than half of the villages do not have an evacuation plan

More than half of the villages in the “Safe Villages, Safe People” program do not have a defined evacuation plan. The program covers more than 2,200 villages.

Created in 2018, the “Safe Villages, Safe People” programs aim to create protection zones and places of refuge, prevent people from fires and reduce the consequences in case of fires and possible evacuations.

There are currently 2,255 villages involved in this program. According to data provided by Jornal de Notícias, in the year of creation of the program, in 2018,

There were 1,793 villages, from then on the number has always increased. +170 in 2019, +29 villages in 2020, +65 in 2021, +176 in 2022 and lastly 12 villages in this last year, the lowest number of new villages ever.

The internet portal also shows that of the total of 2255 villages, only 918 villages have an evacuation plan, that is, more than half do not have this plan defined, but there is an increase compared to last year, of 60 new plans.

The latest data from this month show that Guarda, Bragança and Viseu are the districts with the most safe villages:

Guarda has 503 villages, 59 more than the previous year.

Bragança and Viseu have not changed in relation to last year.

The initially defined goal was 7,000 villages by the end of 2030.

In response to SIC, the National Emergency and Civil Protection Authority says that these targets may be revised but that the balance of municipalities and parishes is, so far, positive.

 

Portugal Safety and Security Report Wednesday 7th August 2023

 

By David Thomas

Good afternoon everyone, the last few days have been dominated by the rural fires ion the mainland in particular the Odemira fire which was active for five days and was brought under resolution earlier today.

This and many of the other fires were largely predictable given the high temperatures, maximum fire risk in many parts of the country and fire danger at “extreme” and above in certain areas. Civil protection pre-positioned many resources in high risk areas accordingly. I outlined this on KissFm radio of Sunday and I hopefully the advice helped people in preparing and dealing with such fires.

It is important, however, to note that in forest fires it is not the high temperatures that produces the fires. In general it is human activity, often by carelessness, sometimes intentionally. The fires are facilitated by the existence of these high temperatures, the low humidity of the air, which make the vegetation dry and is more likely for it to ignite, and spread. We have to be even more careful. Unfortunately, we see that this is not what happens. Often, people undertake activities that they think will not have any consequences and cause these fires.

Safe Communities Portugal monitored the Odemira fire from the start and we created a major incident page on our website. To make it easier to follow. It was apparent from the outset that this would be a difficult fire to suppress, due to many factors such and deep and enclosed valleys which are difficult to access on land by fire fighters and track machines, the variable weather with high temperatures and in particular gusty and variable wind conditions sometimes up to 80 km/h.

These challenges were described by ANEPC as; “an area of interest approaching 9,000 ha, characterized by extensive areas of pine forest, adult and young eucalyptus, cork oaks, strawberry trees and bushes and a scattered building and rural/urban interface zones that required a dispersion of combat means for actions to protect the populations and protected heritage. As a result of the steep slope with embedded valleys, along with the constant reactivations, these became quickly out of suppression capacity, aggravated by the lack of conditions conducive to progression with crawler machines in the consolidation process”.

Taking advantage of improved weather conditions overnight 8th/9th August the fire has been brought to a resolution today, but with increasing temperatures in the Algarve later today, with an orange level warning in place, some reactivations are inevitable.

Since the beginning of the year, more than 5,529 fire events have already affected 19,106 hectares of rural areas. Yesterday: there 153 and 170 on Monday.

The question also arose whether or not the government should declare a Situation of Alert to help deal with the outbreak of fires.

Secretary of State for Civil Protection announced this was being assessed on Sunday, taking into account the operational response to combat the fires and weather conditions. However, “as time progressed”, and based on a permanent daily assessment, “the situation began to change slightly” to a meteorological picture quite different from the one that we had initially in the middle of the afternoon of Sunday”. Therefore, it is necessary to understand that this is an instrument absolutely exceptional, as well as the declaration of the state of contingency.

Let us hope that we do not have to embark on these sort of measures as we did in 2022 during the heatwave, when there were more fires over a longer period.

The response to the creation of our new Facebook group, Safe Communities Portugal has exceeded expectations with close to 1700 members in just 40 days since it was formed. This group fills a vacuum as its aim is to increase risk awareness and preparedness, so everyone knows how to reduce the impact of major disasters where possible and action to take during such events. We have covered major fire events and will continue to do so during the months ahead. We ask people to monitor closely weather reports and in particular fire risks and dangers.

With that please have a safe week ahead.